Council leaders have defended funding allocations for net zero projects in York amid claims they received a disproportionate amount of money to North Yorkshire.
A joint meeting of the Conservative-run North Yorkshire and Labour-run City of York councils to discuss the expected creation of a mayoral combined authority in January heard while the councils had agreed on how to split the first significant tranche of government devolution funding, uncertainty still surrounds the transfer of powers from Westminster.
Ahead of the meeting opposition councillors in North Yorkshire claimed the proposed division of the funds for net zero schemes would see York receive 47% of £6.2m being spent on capital schemes, despite having a population of about a third the size of North Yorkshire.
A total of 23 schemes will receive a share of the funding unlocked by the region’s proposed devolution deal, subject to devolution progressing for York and North Yorkshire.
They include street and building LED lighting schemes in York as well as innovation in energy generation, including The Electric Cow Project at Askham Bryan College in the city.
Read more:
- North Yorkshire Conservatives dismiss claims over residents’ questions ban
- County-wide zone has damaged taxi businesses, says Ripon councillor
The farming scheme will fund slurry-fuelled conversion equipment for dairy farms across the region to generate electricity from cow manure.
Other projects approved aim to tackle a decline of biodiversity, such as the project at the Denton Park Estate, on the edge of the Yorkshire Dales, where funds will support moorland restoration.
Critics of the proposed net zero programme have claimed York residents will benefit from millions of pounds of extra funding at the expense of communities across the vast rural county.
However, York and North Yorkshire Local Enterprise Partnership boss James Farrar told the meeting the schemes which were being funded represented “a good spread” across the area, including ones in York and every constituency in North Yorkshire.
Countering the criticism, leaders of both councils heralded the investment as a milestone for the region, with North Yorkshire Council leader Cllr Carl Les saying it was “a very exciting time”.
City of York Council’s leader Cllr Claire Douglas said addressing climate change was becoming increasingly important and the proposals represented the first cross-region thinking, rather than for York or for North Yorkshire as entities.
She said:
Police commissioner rejects advice to delay appointment of chief constable“It’s really fantastic to see there’s such a wide coverage of the region.
“I think it’s also fantastic to see that this is the first significant investment that the combined authority is able to commit to.”
North Yorkshire’s police commissioner has rejected advice to delay the appointment of a new chief constable.
The current chief constable, Lisa Winward, announced last month she will retire on March 31, 2024.
As a result, members of North Yorkshire and York’s police, fire and crime panel, which met at City of York Council yesterday, urged Conservative commissioner Zoë Metcalfe to postpone the recruitment process for up to 15 months.
Ms Winward’s retirement will come just weeks before a new Mayor of York and North Yorkshire, who will take on police commissioner powers including the ability to appoint a chief constable, will be elected.
The panel felt the delay would ensure senior police officers had sufficient time to see eye-to-eye with the new mayor.
Ms Metcalfe, however, rejected the guidance today. She felt months of temporary leadership would not be in the public’s best interest.
She said:
“As the single elected individual with responsibility for the totality of policing and crime for York and North Yorkshire, I have a duty to ensure that the force has outstanding, inspirational long-term leadership to keep our communities safe and feeling safe.
“I was surprised that some panel members saw fit to substitute their preference, not just for my decision, but for the considered professional views of all national stakeholders with a remit for excellence in police leadership.
“It gives me no pleasure to say that the recommendations of those key national stakeholders outweigh the panel’s recommendation.
“I stand by my decision.”
Ms Metcalfe added:
“This is a crucial time for the programme of improvements for North Yorkshire Police.
“The role of chief constable of North Yorkshire Police is a terrific opportunity for an inspirational, visionary chief police officer.
“The process for selection will be open, rigorous, exciting and challenging – and will involve a broad range of local and national key partner organisations so that York and North Yorkshire can be sure that we have the very best of police leadership for our communities.”
The move comes as members of the panel raised concern that the selection of the chief constable would coincide with the election of the Mayor for York and North Yorkshire.
Cllr Lindsay Burr, who represents Malton, said it would be an incorrect decision for the public to appoint a chief constable when the force’s strategic direction had not been set by the incoming mayor.
Huby councillor and former police officer Malcolm Taylor said while moving ahead with recruiting a chief constable might be a good decision in the short-term, the appointment was a long-term role.
Meanwhile, Ms Metcalfe also rejected an option to appoint an interim chief constable earlier this month.
The Stray Ferret reported that the commissioner was also given alternatives, including appointing the deputy chief constable to role until after mayoral election, but turned down both options in favour of starting a recruitment process.
Read more:
- Call for North Yorkshire police commissioner to delay chief constable appointment
- Police commissioner Zoe Metcalfe rejects appointing interim chief constable
Council to pay additional £1m in North Yorkshire combined authority set-up cost
North Yorkshire Council looks set to pay an additional £1 million to set up a combined authority for the county and York.
The combined authority, which will be headed by an elected mayor, is scheduled to be launched in November this year.
It will include councillors from North Yorkshire Council and City of York Council and make decisions on matters such as economic development and transport.
So far, North Yorkshire Council has footed £582,000 worth of costs for consultation and staff redeployment to help set up the combined authority.
In a report due before a joint devolution committee next week, the council will be recommended to fund a further £1 million in costs ahead of its implementation in four months time.
The money would cover areas such as IT infrastructure, project management, human resources and contingency plans.
However, the council has said that it expects the cash to be paid back once government funding for the combined authority is released.
It said:
“North Yorkshire Council will continue to cash flow the implementation and set up costs of the combined authority on the understanding that these costs will be repaid once funding is released on creation of the combined authority in November.”
Councillors will discuss the funding at a meeting on July 24.
What is a combined authority?
A combined authority is a body set up for two or more councils to make joint decisions.
In this case, North Yorkshire Council and City of York Council would come together to make decisions on matters such as economic development and transport.
Read more:
- Conservatives select highways councillor Keane Duncan to stand for North Yorkshire mayor
- Explained: What is North Yorkshire’s combined authority?
It will be a separate body to North Yorkshire Council and City of York Council.
The closest example of this is West Yorkshire Combined Authority, which recently has led on the £11.9 million Harrogate Station Gateway scheme, as well as similar schemes in Skipton and Selby.
The combined authority would be headed by a mayor who is directly elected by the public.
An election for the Mayor of York and North Yorkshire is set to be held in May 2024.
The Conservatives selected Cllr Keane Duncan, the executive member for highways and transportation at North Yorkshire Council, at a meeting on Friday.
GALLERY: Conservation, cheese and cattle take centre stage at Great Yorkshire Show
This story is sponsored by Harrogate BID
Successes in agriculture and champion cattle, cheese, pigeons and forestry were recognised on day two of the Great Yorkshire Show.
Spectators were treated to the stunt riding of Lorenzo in the main ring and Adam Henson’s chat show returned to the GYS stage.
The day also saw the supreme pigeon award presented to a Chinese Owl from Huworth.
The third national cattle championship at the show, the British Charolais, went to a two-year-old heifer, Marne Sweetpea, owned by Robert Tremayne and Nicola Osgood of Kent.
Day two also saw the inaugural farmland curlew award developed by the Yorkshire Agricultural Society and Nidderdale AONB to reward famers who make a significant contribution to curlew conservation — won by two Cumbrian beef and sheep farmers.
Future Farmers also had their flagship annual get-together and held a panel-led discussion.
York Community Woodland, owned by City of York Council and tenanted by Forestry England, took home the John Broddy trophy for the best new woodland in Yorkshire awarded by the Yorkshire Agricultural Society, Royal Forestry Society and Forestry Commission.
Tickets for the show have now sold out and will not be available on the gate. The opening times are 8am to 6pm on all four days. To see what is happening on which day, visit here.
Take a look at the gallery below to catch up on today’s highlights.

Pic: Great Yorkshire Show website

Mill Hill School pupils celebrating their success

Horticap’s award-winning garden

The Yorkshire Air Ambulance team

A hound class


Artist: Jonny Sunter

Pic: Great Yorkshire Show website


Pic: Great Yorkshire Show website

Biscuit of Farlavale Gun Dogs

Pic: Great Yorkshire Show website
Read more:
- GALLERY: Royal visit marks start of Harrogate’s Great Yorkshire Show
- Harrogate businesses offering unmissable discounts to attract punters during Great Yorkshire Show