North Yorkshire Council has refused a plan to build 18 holiday cabins in a woodland near Knaresborough.
The Hargreaves family submitted plans this year for the tourism business, which included wooden shepherds huts, cabins and pods nestled within a woodland just outside the village of Coneythorpe.
Documents submitted by the applicants said they wanted to create a “tranquil overnight accommodation scheme in a unique location” that would be a base for tourists to explore North Yorkshire.
A new footpath was also proposed to the village which it said would increase footfall to the Tiger Inn pub and support the social and economic wellbeing of Coneythorpe.
The plans received 14 comments with one in support and 13 objecting.
But with strict planning laws in the countryside, the council refused the plans this week saying the site is outside the development limits of the village and the proposal does not demonstrate that the scheme requires a rural location.
Planning officer Trevor Watson wrote that the huts would not be accessible to existing local services, public facilities or tourist attractions and the proposal would not promote sustainable travel.
There were also concerns about a loss of trees in the woodland with the applicants not proposing to replant them on a two-for-one basis.
Mr Watson wrote:
“The cumulative effect of the proposed cabins, pods, shepherd huts, office, accesses and car park together with the change in activity and associated tourism paraphernalia would result in a visually intrusive and detrimental change to the agricultural and woodland character of the site.
“The proposal would fail to protect, enhance and restore the landscape character of the site and would result in substantial harm to the character and appearance of the conservation area. There are no public benefits associated with the proposal that would outweigh the harm.”
The applicants can appeal the decision.
Read more:
- How the wheels came off Knaresborough’s bid to win bed race
- Knaresborough housebuilder up for sale as operations paused
How Stean Gorge set to build luxury cabins for groups and families
How Stean Gorge is set to build 10 holiday cabins to entice more groups and families.
Currently the gorge, which has been a visitor attraction for more than 100 years, can only accomodate people prepared to camp.
Work is due to start in January 2022 on the first phase of the plan with construction set for completion in April 2022.
The first phase includes six of the cabins and a manager’s cabin.
The second phase can only start when Harrogate Borough Council is satisfied that trees planted as part of landscaping are mature enough not to be affected by more building works.
Read more:
- Station Gateway hit with second petition calling for project to be halted
- Free Harrogate buses every Sunday in January and February
It means that the remaining four cabins could be a few years away.
The cabins vary in size. The rustic lodges can sleep up to 10 people but there are also chalets with room for six or four people.
All of them will be built in a log cabin style on stilts with a covered veranda and a log burner inside. The centre is also looking at sourcing hot tubs for the cabins.

Abseiling at How Stean Gorge. Photo: Gerard Binks
Tony Liddy, the head of outdoor education and estates manager, told the Stray Ferret:
“We got a lot of stag dos and hen dos as well as families at How Stean Gorge. Unfortunately for a while now the closest group accomodation has been in Harrogate.
“We are keeping the campsite but that is not always for everyone. So these cabins are going to be a big step forward for the site. It’s very exciting.”
How Stean Gorge is also planning to bring back its Vista Bistro experience where people can dine in a restaurant sat over the drop. Currently it has two dates in the calendar, March 19 and April 2.